A ‘why choose’ romance is when a main character has more than one love interest, and instead of picking One True Love, she HEAs with multiple partners.
‘Why choose’ covers a myriad of other subtropes: throuples, reverse harem, polyamory and more! It’s a trope that allows for complex relationship dynamics, (occasional) angst, and some HOT spice!
Here are a few of our fave romantasy reads that feature the ‘why choose’ trope as a main or secondary romantic plot.
Blood of Hercules by Jasmine Mas
Trope alert: Reverse Harem
Alexis Hert isn’t a hero, and she certainly isn’t a god. All she’s ever been is a survivor.
But the Fates disagree.
When a blood test leads to her admittance at the Spartan War Academy, she’ll have to do more than merely survive.
Alexis will have to claim her birthright: immortality.
But immortality is a privilege, one earned in the crucible of the academy, where the heroes are villains and classrooms battlegrounds. While gladiators Achilles and Patro, her demanding mentors, hone her into a warrior, Augustus and Kharon, her professors and the brooding heirs to the underworld, haunt her steps and her thoughts.
Because where there are gods, there are bound to be monsters, and there is more than one hunting Alexis…
Warrior, Princess, Assassin by Brigid Kemmerer
Trope alert: Throuple
Who should you trust?
Warrior King Maddox Kyronan’s fire magic has earned him a ruthless reputation. But now his kingdom is slowly burning, a blaze he cannot control, and his one chance to save it is a marriage alliance with the neighbouring royal family of Astranza and their power to manipulate the weather.
Who should you love?
As war looms on the horizon, Princess Jory’s home needs this alliance. But her family is hiding a dangerous secret: their magic is fading. When she meets her intended he sets her heart aflame, but what will he do when he realises she’s deceiving him?
Who should you kill?
Once a young nobleman causing mischief with Jory in Astranza’s palace, Asher is now part of the Hunter’s Guild. When a lucrative job arises, he can’t refuse – until he sees the targets. Someone wants King Maddox and Princess Jory dead. Now Asher must decide what he’s willing to do to protect the woman he loves and the king she’s about to marry.
Bonded by Thorns by Elizabeth Helen
Trope alert: Reverse Harem
- Four handsome fae princes.
- One awkward bookworm.
- An Enchanted Vale.
- A beastly curse to break.
Rosalina O’Connell lives her life in Orca Cove as quietly as she can.
When her father turns up missing, Rosie goes after him and finds herself in the Enchanted Vale, the land of the fae. Where her father has been imprisoned and Rosie has no choice but to make a deal with four fae Princes to take his place.
As Rosie begins to learn more about the four Princes, she discovers that they have been cursed. The Princes must take on the form of demonic wolves every night and with every year that passes, more of their magic fades away.
If the Princes can each find their mate, they will break their curse and free their realm. Rosie is determined to help them…
The only problem is, the more time she spends with the Princes, the more she’s convinced that she’s the one they’re all meant to be with.
A spicy Beauty and the Beast retelling filled with enchanted fae, morally grey characters, a stupidly hot villain and a princess who has found her Prince Charming. All four of them.
With Hearts of Flame by Briar Boleyn
Trope alert: Throuple
I thought surviving a vampire academy was the hardest thing I’d ever have to do. Then I fell in love with a boy who can turn into a dragon.
After the attack on Veilmar, I should help to keep the school running. But instead, I’ve been pulled into a secret dwarven quest to recover something the other side can never be allowed to claim. The only problem? The enemy is down here with us – and they’re already ahead.
Back at Bloodwing, our friends are caught between the demands of the highblood elite and the fragile revolution blooming in the halls. Regan must reclaim a title she once wielded cruelly. But this time she’ll use it to protect the students she helped oppress.
Meanwhile, far to the north, another fight is unfolding. At the Bonewood, love has become both a weapon and a weakness.
As dragons rise, the dead stir, and an ancient prophecy tightens its grip, my friends and I must choose once and for all what we’re willing to sacrifice for a better world.
Feathers So Vicious by Liv Zander
Trope alert: Throuple
More treacherous than war… are the battles within a heart.
Perched between branches and shadows,
We watch, we scheme,
Fighting for a kingdom forgotten and forlorn.
Until we rip her away with our claws,
Our prisoner, our pawn, our plaything.
Caught between our feathers,
She endures our deranged desires,
Our secrets, our lies,
Our twisted plans.
Will she surrender to our darkness,
or fight for a destiny growing ever elusive?
Welcome to the Court of Ravens, little white dove.
Get the book here
Queen of Air and Darkness by Cassandra Clare
Trope alert: Throuple
Dark secrets and forbidden love threaten the very survival of the Shadowhunters in Cassandra Clare’s Queen of Air and Darkness, the final novel in the #1 New York Times and USA TODAY bestselling The Dark Artifices trilogy.
Innocent blood has been spilled on the steps of the Council Hall, the sacred stronghold of the Shadowhunters.
In the wake of the tragic death of Livia Blackthorn, the Clave teeters on the brink of civil war. One fragment of the Blackthorn family flees to Los Angeles, seeking to discover the source of the disease that is destroying the race of warlocks.
Meanwhile, Julian and Emma take desperate measures to put their forbidden love aside and undertake a perilous mission to Faerie to retrieve the Black Volume of the Dead. What they find in the Courts is a secret that may tear the Shadow World asunder and open a dark path into a future they could never have imagined.
Caught in a race against time, Emma and Julian must save the world of Shadowhunters before the deadly power of the parabatai curse destroys them and everyone they love.
Happy reading!
Brothers of the Vine
Forever Evermore
Women of W.A.R.